In addition to his success on the track, Williams saw tremendous success on the football field as well. In his two seasons with the Patriots, Williams tallied 2,711 all-purpose yards, 783 receiving yards with 11 touchdowns, 1,471 kick return yards, and 316 rushing yards with four touchdowns. In 2014, his first season with UC, Williams earned MSC Second-Team All-Conference honors as a return specialist after tallying 694 return yards and an 83-yard return for a touchdown. He averaged 77.1 return yards per game and finished the year ranked seventh in the NAIA averaging 27.8 yards per return. Williams carried his success into the 2015 season as he led the NAIA averaging 32.4 yards per kick off return and ranked second in the country with 777 kickoff return yards. Williams’ most memorable game against Carson-Newman when he rewrote the record book recording five returns for 287 yards, including a 97-yard and 98-yard return for a touchdown, breaking the school record for most returns yards in a game and most kickoff return for a touchdown in a game. His efforts earned Williams NAIA Special Teams Player of the Week. Williams went on to be named an NAIA Second Team All-American and a First Team All-Conference selection that season.